Most everyone who knows me, knows I am a bit of an electronics addict. I always have some gadget that I am pining for; some future purchase or soon to be released item that I want. I try to be as rational as possible. I try to wait when buying a new Windows Mobile device at least 2 product cycles. A new computer purchase must wait 4 years. And MP3 players anything over a year will do. While this is more often than many people, this is considered a late adopter in the Tech world.
This is why I surprised myself by buying a Zune. There were many reasons that I shouldn't buy it. I already had an MP3 player that was less than a year old. The Zune followed the same closed system that I had admonished iPod fans for buying into. I also had avoided Hard Drive players in favor of flash based systems that made for better running companions. Not to mention, the Zune was a first release of a new product line; one that may or may not even succeed.

But after Christmas I found myself with some Best Buy gift cards and an irrational desire to own a Zune. My 6 Gig flash player worked great, but my music collection had grown beyond capacity. I loved the Senza for running, but I missed having every song that I owned with me. I missed not being able to play just the right song for an occasion because that one that I wanted to hear right now didn't make the sync. Also, I was a little surprised by the accessories already offered with the Zune. I mean it was no iPod, but I had waited 6 months for a docking station for my Senza and it still didn't work. Microsoft worked hard to get accessories released, and if anyone can come close to rivaling the ipod in this regard, they can.
Am I happy with the purchase? Absolutely. It does everything I wanted and more. I was always cautious about what songs I added to my player due to it's limited size. Not to mention now I have size for video clips, TV shows and every picture I own. The interface is unbeleavable. Many complain that it doesn't have a real scroll wheel, trust me these people have not played with it to form a real opinion. It is so much easer to find a song by holding your finger down than by going around in circles. Not to mention the screens are much more intuitive than the ipod's interface. The twist menus allow you to navigate in two directions making it easy to get where you want to go.
Is the Zune going to beat the ipod? Not in the near future. As slick as it is, the interface is not enough for people to want to switch. And the added WiFi is more of a ' watch this space' feature. There are not enough Zunes out to let you share songs, and Microsoft themselves have stated that the WiFi will do more soon. So we wait. Not to mention Microsoft does not have Apple's cachet. Nowadays, if you don't have an ipod, you have some sort of cheap knockoff in the eyes of the Apple fanboys. And everyone and their dog have lined up to criticize the Zune simply because it is not an ipod.
But what the ipod crowd does not realize is that Apple has stagnated. The ipod, while it is great in it's simplicity, releases some small new feature every year with no real leap. Competition from the Zune is just what the ipod, and all MP3 players in general, need: Someone to force a leap. Remember the days of Netscape and Internet Explorer. The competition forced each to release a new version, with new features often. When IE faced no competition it stagnated with little innovation. Then along comes Firefox and low-and-behold we get a new version of IE with tons of new features.
And for those who say that the Zune will never win out over the ipod...be carefull. Remember when Microsoft entered the game console market which was dominated by Sony. They spent years as a distant third behind even Nintendo. Now they have changed the market and forced all the competitors to innovate with High Def and off-the-wall controllers. Also remember how everyone had a Palm, much like everyone has an ipod today. Palm, like Apple had stagnated. Now Blackberry and Windows Mobile dominate the landscape and you are hard-pressed to find a Palm outside of someone's junk drawer.
So while there were many reasons for me not to choose a Zune, I am very happy with the decision. Will I still be happy a year or two from now...only time will tell.
.